Ex parte AHARON et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 96-3762                                                          
          Application No. 08/245,179                                                  


          absence of further limitations which require more than merely               
          processing input.                                                           
          Figure 5 of Loopik shows a data base 62 for providing                       
          data to a test program generator 64, which meets the claimed                
          "storing means."  Although Loopik does not state that the data              
          base stores data which is represented as a separate                         
          declarative specifi-ation, the definition given by appellants               
          (specification, page 5) for "separate declarative                           
          specification" simply requires a data base.  Accordingly, the               
          data of Loopik's data base appears to be represented as a                   
          separate declarative specification.                                         
               Each independent claim recites "data representing a                    
          processor instruction set and resources" and "the declarative               
          specification being a representation of relationships between               
          semantic entities associated with each instruction and between              
          said semantic entities and said processor resources."  As                   
          stated above, the circuit assembly can be considered a                      
          processor, but only if no further claim limitations require                 
          more than merely processing data.  The second paragraph, as                 
          quoted above, further distinguishes the processor.                          
          Accordingly, whether the circuit assembly of Loopik can serve               

                                         -4-                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007