Ex parte CHAMBERLIN - Page 2




                  Appeal No. 97-0455                                                                                                                         
                  Application No. 08/344,043                                                                                                                 
                  two-stroke cycle engines and a method of lubricating a particular type of these engines, crankcase-                                        
                  scavenged two-stroke cycle engines.  Such engines were known in the art as of applicant’s effective filing                                 
                  date.  Applicant describes these engines as follows:                                                                                       
                                              Direct fuel-injected crankcase-scavenged two-stroke cycle engines have                                         
                                    been described in some detail on page 37 of the present application.  These are                                          
                                    engines in which the lubricant is not pre-mixed with the fuel . . . .  The fuel is                                       
                                    injected directly into the combustion chamber, rather than being drawn through the                                       
                                    crankcase.  The lubricant and air, on the other hand are drawn into the crankcase                                        
                                    and are pumped or scavenged from there and ultimately pass into the combustion                                           
                                    chamber.  There they are compressed, and thereafter the fuel is injected.  In the                                        
                                    ordinary two-stroke cycle engine on the other hand, the fuel and lubricant are                                           
                                    premixed, supplied to the crankcase, swept promptly into the combustion                                                  
                                    chamber, and consumed.                                                                                                   
                  Response to Request for Additional Information (Paper 16), p. 13:                                                                          
                           As set out in the claims, lubricant compositions require three components: (1) an oil of lubricating                              
                  viscosity; (2) a piston scuffing preventing or reducing amount of the mixture of a phenol and a dispersant;                                
                  and (3) an antioxidant.  Bright stock may be included as an optional component in some embodiments.  The                                   
                  lubricant must also be free of ash forming and phosphorous containing components.   Applicant’s                                            
                  specification indicates that the ashless dispersants include Mannich, amine, nitrogen-containing carboxylic,                               
                  and  ester dispersants.  These dispersants may be  post treated with boron compounds.  Specification                                       
                  (Paper 1),  p. 22, lines 19-25.                                                                                                            
                           Claim 1 limits the phenol to either (1) an aminophenol or (2) the reaction product of a nitrophenol                               
                  and an amino compound.  The dispersant is limited to Mannich, amine, nitrogen-containing carboxylic, or                                    
                  ester dispersants.  The antioxidant is limited to sulfur-containing organic, nitrogen-containing, or hindered                              
                  phenol inhibitors. Bright stock, if present, is limited to no more than 3%.   Claim 41 is essentially the same,                            
                  limiting phenol to an aminophenol and the antioxidant to an aromatic amine.                                                                
                           Claim 21 is directed to the method of using the lubricant essentially as specified in claim 1 to                                  
                  lubricate a fuel-injected, crankcase-scavenged two-stroke cycle engine.  There are two steps to the                                        
                  method: (1) supplying the lubricant to the crankcase of the engine and (2) operating the engine. The steps                                 
                                                                            -2-                                                                              





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007