Ex parte CHIANG - Page 12




          Appeal No. 97-0642                                                          
          Application 08/242,318                                                      

          (e.g., katakana) to a different text domain (e.g., kanji)                   
          (Br12).  The conversion in Kato is completely automatic.                    
               Sklarew alone appears to meet the limitations of claim 1.              
          As discussed, handwritten characters are from "one text                     
          domain" (a "source text domain") and the font symbol                        
          characters are from "another text domain" (a "destination text              
          domain").  The computer in Sklarew identifies text in a window              
          as being selected, e.g., the window shown in figure 12C.                    
          While it is implied that Sklarew automatically converts                     
          handwriting as it is entered, Sklarew also discloses that                   
          conversion of the handwritten input to the corresponding font               
          symbol may be initiated by pressing the "MATCH" softkey                     
          (misspelled as "HATCH" in figures 12D and 12E; col. 12,                     
          lines 41-63).  Sklarew discloses that editing "functions are                
          accomplished with handwritten Editing Symbols on the                        
          (optional) screen or by touching the Softkeys with the stylus"              
          (col. 10, lines 50-53), where the editing symbols are editing               
          "gestures."  This teaching would have suggested to one of                   
          ordinary skill in the art of designing stylus-based interfaces              
          that other functions, such as the conversion function, could                
          be initiated by either a handwritten symbol (gesture) or a key              

                                       - 12 -                                         





Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007