Ex parte CHIANG - Page 7




          Appeal No. 97-0642                                                          
          Application 08/242,318                                                      

          we summarize the grouping of claims as follows using                        
          Appellant's issue letters from the Brief:                                   
               Issue B.  In the rejection of claims 1-7 over Sklarew and              
          Kato, claims 1-6 stand or fall together and claim 7 stands or               
          falls separately.                                                           
               Issue C.  In the rejection of claims 8-20 over Sklarew,                
          Kato, and Capps, claim 10 stands or falls with independent                  
          claim 1 because it has not been separately argued; claims 8,                
          9, and 16-18 stand or fall as one group; and claims 10-15, 19,              
          and 20 stand or fall together as another group.                             
               Issue D.  In the rejection of claims 21-23 over Capps and              
          Kato, claims 21-23 stand or fall together.                                  
               Issue E.  In the rejection of claims 24-37, which we                   
          treat as a rejection of claims 24-27, over Sklarew, Horodeck,               
          and Kato, claims 24-26 stand or fall together and claim 27                  
          stands or falls separately.                                                 
               [Issue F.] In the rejection of claims 28-37 over Sklarew,              
          Horodeck, Kato, and Capps, claim 30 stands or falls with                    
          independent claim 24 because it has not been separately                     
          argued; claims 28 and 29 stand or fall as one group; and                    
          claims 31-37 stand or fall together as another group.                       

                                        - 7 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007