Ex parte YAMAKOSHI et al. - Page 8




          Appeal No. 97-1167                                         Page 8           
          Application No. 08/475,062                                                  


               harmonic distortion of the reproduced signal.                          
               Decision circuit 26 compares the second harmonic                       
               distortion with a reference 28.  Current driver 12                     
               adjusts the bias current based on the output of                        
               decision circuit 26.  (Id.)                                            

          He concludes that it would have been obvious to combine                     
          Ottesen with Admission “to provide dynamic control of a                     
          reproducing head, to maintain it at an optimum operating point              
          ....”  (Id. at 5-6.)                                                        
          The examiner admits that the combination of Admission in view               
          of Ottesen “lacks a circuit for measuring the signal to noise               
          ratio of the reproduced signal.”  (Id. at 6.)                               


               He notes that Shimotashiro “selects the bias current                   
          value as an optimum value for maximizing an overall S/N ratio.              
          Adder 12 combines the S/N ratio resulting from noise with a                 
          S/N ratio resulting from distortion.  In this way,                          
          Shimotashiro ... teach[es] combining noise and distortion                   
          measurement to optimize bias current.”  (Id.)  The examiner                 
          concludes that it would have been obvious to combine                        
          Shimotashiro with Ottesen in view of  Admission “to enable a                
          higher recording rate and increase efficiency ....”  (Id.)                  








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007