Ex parte TSUTSUI et al. - Page 10




          Appeal No. 97-1622                                                          
          Application No. 08/109,179                                                  


                    input space quantization means for quantizing an                  
               input space having the input data from case data                       
               indicating a plurality of past input data and past                     
               single output data stored in advance, in accordance                    
               with a required precision of the single output data;                   
                    storage means for calculating a number of times                   
               of occurrence  of the single output data                               
               corresponding to each input event in the input space                   
               quantized by said input space quantization means, a                    
               mean value     of the single output data, and a mean                   
               value of change amounts of the single output data,                     
               and for storing a set of the number of times of                        
               occurrence and the mean values as a causal                             
               relationship model;                                                    
               The Examiner argues (answer, pages 7 and 8) that the very              
          act of setting up a histogram would necessary include                       
          quantizing of input space.  On this point we reiterate our                  
          earlier discussion of the “quantization” teachings of Hanson.               
          We agree with appellants argument on pages 5-7 of the reply                 
          brief  that although Hanson discloses a quantization of data,               
          such is not a quantization which relates input data to a                    
          required precision of single output data nor does it result in              
          the development of a causal relationship model as claimed.                  
               Claims 2-5 and 6 are dependent on independent claim 1 and              
          as they include all the limitations of claim 1 the rejection                
          of these claims is also reversed.                                           



                                          10                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007