Appeal No. 1997-1688 Application 08/515,752 An ESD protection circuit for protecting a device which has a power supply which is at a first voltage of approximately 3.3 volts and which interfaces with devices that have a supply voltage which is at a second voltage of approximately 5 volts, said ESD protection circuit comprising: a bond pad, said bond pad subjected to said first voltage or said second voltage; a switching element connected to said bond pad, said switching element becomes conductive upon the occurrence of an ESD event; and a primary protection device connected between said switching element and ground for dissipating an ESD signal, said primary protection device is isolated from said bond pad except during said ESD events. The references relied upon by the examiner as evidence of obviousness are: Murayama JP-58-162065 Sep. 26, 1983 Misu et al. (Misu) JP-61-30075 Feb. 12, 1986 Taira EP-0257774 Mar. 02, 1988 Tailliet EP-0568421 Nov. 03, 1993 Isono et al. (Isono) JP-5-335495 Dec. 17, 1993 Claims 28-33 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103 as being unpatentable over Isono, Tailliet, Misu, Murayama or Taira. The respective positions of the examiner and the appellants with regard to the propriety of these rejections are set forth in 2Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007