Appeal No. 1997-1698 Application No. 08/348,447 This appeal is from the final rejection of claims 8-10, 13 and 14, all the claims pending in the application. The invention pertains to a device for determining the presence or absence of surface roughening. Claim 8, the only independent claim, is illustrative and reads as follows: 8. A portable device for determining the presence or absence of surface roughening, comprising: a hand-held enclosure including a window to be placed adjacent and moved along a surface to be characterized; a light source disposed within the enclosure to project a beam of light through the window and onto a localized area of the surface, the path of the beam reflected by the surface and back through the window defining an optical axis; a light-sensitive detector disposed on the optical axis within the enclosure to receive light scattered by the surface and output an electrical signal representative of the light received; an optical blocking element supported within the enclosure at a point along the optical axis between the window and the detector to block the beam when reflected by a substantially non-roughened surface; a lens supported within the enclosure along the optical axis at a point between the window and the blocking element to gather light scattered off-axis by a roughened surface and focus the gathered light onto the detector; a two-state indicator disposed on the enclosure; and 2Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007