Ex parte BONUTTI et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 97-2550                                                          
          Application 08/467,698                                                      


               retractor 140 includes a sleeve 14 with an expanding                   
               portion 60 including a plurality of expanding arms                     
               62.  The body portion [12] of the retractor 140 has                    
               a pointed distal end 142 for easier passage through                    
               tissues.  Proximal to the threaded portion 22 of the                   
               retractor body [12], a portion 144 of the retractor                    
               includes a fluid supply port 146.  An inflatable                       
               bladder 150 is bonded to the retractor sleeve 14 at                    
               two circumferential, axially spaced locations 152                      
               and 154.  Appropriate fluid passages are provided in                   
               the retractor body and the retractor sleeve to                         
               provide fluid communication between the fluid supply                   
               port 146 and the bladder 150.  The bladder can be                      
               deflated with suction [column 8, lines 18 through                      
               31].                                                                   

               As tacitly conceded by the examiner (see page 3 in the                 
          answer), Bonutti does not respond to the limitations in                     
          independent appealed claim 12 calling for the claimed cannula               
          to include a plurality of wires and a variable volume chamber               


          conduit which are enclosed by and extend along an inner side                
          of a sheath, with the conduit being disposed between adjacent               
          wires.                                                                      
               Lee discloses a catheter tubing 10 having one or more                  
          stiffening "stripes" or wires 20 disposed longitudinally                    
          therein to provide the tubing with a desired balance of                     
          pliability and stiffness.                                                   

                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007