Ex parte GRAHAM - Page 5




          Appeal No. 97-2746                                                          
          Application 08/399,693                                                      


          function of Fonden’s high pressure receptacle 5, pressure                   
          reducing valve 8 and low pressure channel/reservoir 15 respond              
          fully to the rather broad claim recitations involving the                   
          primary or first air supply tank, the pressure reducing valve               
          and the secondary or second air supply tank, respectively.  As              
          pointed out by the appellant, however, “Fonden et al. do not                
          describe with any particularity the source of the air used to               
          charge first tank 5" (brief, page 5).  As a result, Fonden                  
          does not meet the limitations in claim 1                                    




          requiring the continuous coupling of a supply of air from an                
          air compressor to the primary air supply tank, the limitations              
          in claim 2 requiring a compressor to be coupled to the primary              
          air supply tank, or the limitations in claim 3 requiring that               
          pressure be maintained in the first tank by providing a                     
          continuously available fluid coupling from a compressor to the              
          first tank so that the first tank is replenished when                       
          necessary by the compressor.                                                
               Thus, Fonden does not disclose each and every element of               
          the subject matter recited in claims 1 through 3.                           
                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007