Ex parte MICHELSON - Page 15




          Appeal No. 97-2888                                                          
          Application 08/389,077                                                      




          Michelson '943 and to mount the support rods on the brackets                
          10                                                                          
          and 12 shown in Michelson '943 using swivel clamps as taught                
          by Heffington.  The motivation for modifying Michelson '943 in              
          such a manner is found in Heffington's teaching that the use                
          of                                                                          
          rotatably adjustable support rods provided with intermediate                
          lateral offsets can be used to mount patient supports to                    
          operating tables of different widths.                                       
               With regard to the "plurality of universal rail clamps"                
          recited in claim 18,  we note that no specific structure of3                                                       
          the clamps is recited for performing the function of                        
          "removably mounting the surgical frame to a variety of                      
          conventional operating tables having different widths and                   
          different sized  side rails."  Accordingly, we agree with the               



               We observe that the preamble of independent claim 18 is inconsistent3                                                                     
          with the body of that claim.  That is, the preamble sets forth "[a]n        
          adjustable surgical frame" whereas the body of the claim, in addition to    
          setting forth details of the adjustable surgical frame, also sets forth a   
          "plurality of universal rail clamps."  Accordingly, we interpret independent
          claim 18 to be directed to the combination of an adjustable surgical frame and
          a plurality of universal rail clamps.                                       
                                         15                                           





Page:  Previous  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007