Ex parte RINCOE et al. - Page 8




          Appeal No. 97-4293                                                          
          Application No. 08/138,396                                                  


          requires only that the read event be accomplished “at a                     
          selected time.”  They also note that claim 27 requires that an              
          array of sensors be scanned, a limitation not present in claim              
          13.                                                                         
               As to the first situation, it is our view that,                        
          notwithstanding the failure of patent claim 13 to recite a                  
          “switch,” it would be understood that there must in fact be                 
          such a device in order to activate the apparatus so that a                  
          read event will occur at a “selected time.”  And, because                   
          claim 13 requires that the selected time be “during an                      
          interval within which the person employs said prosthesis                    
          whereby each respective force signal is used to generate an                 
          output signal indicative of the pressure sensed by the                      
          respective sensor,” we believe one would recognize that the                 
          switch that accomplishes this must be disposed on the                       
          prosthesis.  As for the requirement in claim 27 of scanning an              
          array of sensors to generate the required output signals,                   
          claim 13 recites “a plurality of pressure sensors,” the force               
          signals of which are monitored as a read event.  In our view,               
          this could be accomplished only by scanning an array of                     
          sensors.                                                                    
                                          8                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007