Ex parte ELTGEN - Page 4




          Appeal No. 98-0978                                                          
          Application 08/505,650                                                      



          Love.  According to the examiner, Kanck teaches the method                  
          steps as recited in claim 1 with the exception of the use of                
          an endless web.  The examiner is further of the opinion that                
          Love teaches a method similar to Kanck with the provision of                
          using an endless web.  The examiner notes that Love does not                
          show a material hardenable by heat.  The examiner reaches the               
          conclusion that:                                                            
                    [i]t would have been obvious to one of                            
                    ordinary skill in the art to provide the                          
                    method of Kanck with an endless web in view                       
                    of Love to print a continuous image and                           
                    eliminate printing gaps and shocks caused                         
                    by conventional cylinder mounted printing                         
                    plates                                                            
                    and immediately make a new transfer element                       
                    so as to print an image longer than the                           
                    length of the web [Examiner's Answer,                             
                    page 5].                                                          
          The examiner is further of the opinion that Kanck and Love                  
          also would have rendered obvious the apparatus claim 10 to the              
          extent that claim 10 claims the step of enabling formation of               
          a new intermediate transfer element.  According to the                      
          examiner, this does not require the actual formation of the                 
          element but only that the web of Love would have been able to               
          perform this function due to its thermal inertia properties.                
                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007