Ex parte STARK et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1998-2768                                                        
          Application No. 08/520,802                                                  


          recited in the claim are each isometric exercise routines,                  
          that the monitored “exercise activities of the individual” are              
          the actual isometric exercises performed by the patient                     
          against the restraint of the orthopedic restraining device,                 
          and that such activities define the “actual exercise routine”               
          referred to in clause (d) of the claim. In contrast to the                  
          examiner’s position, we do not view the recitation of                       
          isometric exercises in the preamble of appellants’ claim 41 to              
          be merely a statement of intended use, but instead we view                  
          this recitation as providing a limitation on the claimed                    
          subject                                                                     
          matter as a whole, i.e., that the method of claim 41 is                     
          expressly limited to a method of optimizing “isometric                      
          exercise” and that the body of the claim must be read in this               
          light, and thus as being limited to a target isometric                      
          exercise routine and actual                                                 


          isometric exercise activities which constitute the actual                   
          isometric exercise routine.                                                 
          Like appellants, we note that while the orthopedic                          
          apparatus of Airy may be locked so as to be utilized as a                   
                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007