SANNS V. MARTINEZ - Page 15




          Interference No. 103,446                                                    


          requirements of the count in this interference as of July 21,               
          1988, the date of the stipulation.  Lacotte v. Thomas, 758                  
          F.2d 611, 225 USPQ 633, 634 (Fed. Cir. 1985); Knorr v.                      
          Pearson, 671 F.2d 1368, 1373, 213 USPQ 196, 200 (CCPA 1982);                
          Berges v. Gottstein, 618 F.2d 771, 205 USPQ 691, 695 (CCPA                  
          1980).  Accordingly, we find that the plaques prepared and                  
          tested in February and March of 1986 and those prepared and                 
          tested in March and May 1988, including the "glow box" test                 
          results for said plaques, meet all the requirements of Count 1              
          not later than July 21, 1988, the date the parties have                     
          stipulated Sanns learned from Dr. Gary Freeman from J.M. Huber              
          that WG-2 mica "satisfied the aspect ratio and thickness                    
          limitations of the Count in interference."                                  
                    We consider Martinez' argument that the activity by               
          Marsh on behalf of Sanns in 1986 constitutes an actual                      
          reduction to practice to be unpersuasive.  Martinez has                     
          conceded in their brief that Sanns' own uncorroborated                      
          testimony is insufficient as a matter of law to establish the               
          testimony is reliable (Martinez brief, p.2).  Additionally,                 
          the record establishes that neither Marsh nor Dzikowski nor                 



                                         15                                           





Page:  Previous  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007