KIPOURAS et al. V. BARNHOUSE et al. - Page 27




          Interference No. 103,029                                                    



          proven, clearly constitutes a communication under the case law              
          of derivation.                                                              
                    We are also mindful that an opposing party may                    
          delay, by various procedural maneuvers, a request for                       
          additional discovery or stipulations to make the time period                
          between the opening of the preliminary statements and the                   
          filing of a request to amend a preliminary statement unduly                 
          long.  We have no evidence that such a situation has occurred               
          in this case. However, the fact that stipulations were filed,               
          which the senior                                                            


          party states necessitated the request to amend the preliminary              
          statement, blunts the opposition’s arguments based merely on                
          the length of time that has passed after the preliminary                    
          statements have been opened or that certain witnesses have                  
          already been deposed.                                                       
                    With these facts in mind, it is our conclusion, that              
          Barnhouse was not negligent in preparing the original                       
          preliminary statement, and that due care was exercised in the               
          preparation thereof.  We further are of the view that even                  
          with the exercise of this due care, the omission of the claim               
                                          27                                          





Page:  Previous  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007