Ex parte NAGAI et al. - Page 12




                Appeal No. 1996-2211                                                                                                       
                Application No. 08/018,546                                                                                                 


                Takahashi teaches an improved medium for the culture of bovine embryos.  This medium includes                              

                TCM-199 supplemented with 10% FCS containing 10 or 50 TM cysteamine at 39EC.  Takahashi                                    

                teaches that development to blastocysts was significantly higher when embryos were cultured in a                           

                medium containing 10 and 50 TM cysteamine than when they were cultured in a medium without                                 

                cysteamine.  While Takahashi is silent with regards to transporting steps, a culturing process includes                    

                the step of moving cultures a nominal distance, e.g., the laboratory bench to the “warm box.” Takahashi                    

                does not teach the transport of bovine embryos over a long distance e.g. from a laboratory to a farm for                   

                implantation.  However, Hasler teach that bovine embryos can be safely and effectively transported in a                    

                minimal medium (PBS supplemented with FCS), and under a wide range of transportation conditions.                           

                        In our view, it would have been prima facie obvious to a person of ordinary skill in the art at                    

                the time the invention was made to transport bovine embryos in the improved medium taught by                               

                Takahashi.  Since Hasler demonstrates that bovine embryos can be successfully transported in a                             

                minimal medium, it would have been obvious to maintain the embryos in the improved medium taught                           

                by Takahashi during culture and subsequent transportation, since the improved medium significantly aids                    

                in the development of the embryos.  Furthermore, there would be no reason to replace the improved                          

                Takahashi medium with a different transportation medium given the results obtained by Hasler.                              




                                                                    12                                                                     








Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007