Ex parte CLAES - Page 16




          Appeal No. 1996-3076                                                         
          Application 08/118,773                                                       

          Therefore, we find that Dieter does not anticipate claim 23.                 
          The rejection of claim 23 is reversed.                                       

               Claim 26                                                                
               Claim 26 is similar to claim 10 except that it omits                    
          the limitation about "means for communicating                                
          bidirectionally with the operating system (OS) and the                       
          service program" and adds a "writing means."  We have                        
          addressed the limitations of claim 26 in the discussion of                   
          claim 10 except for the "writing means."                                     
               Appellant argues that "the Examiner has not identified                  
          any identical teaching in Dieter of the writing means of                     
          Claim 26, which enables the monitoring module to send                        
          information directly to the application programs, or the                     
          feature of collected [sic] information on the observed                       
          application program for use by a service program" (Br17).                    
          The Examiner points to (EA5-6) the following statement                       
          (page 200, left column):  "For test and debug purposes the                   
          test software running of DTM phase 1-3 on the TMP can access                 
          any data in the memory of the main processor to read and                     
          modify variables of the tested system."                                      


                                        - 16 -                                         





Page:  Previous  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007