Ex parte CLAES - Page 12




          Appeal No. 1996-3076                                                         
          Application 08/118,773                                                       

          central memory, a keyboard filter, etc., as mentioned on                     
          page 8, lines 4-6, of the specification.                                     
               The processor under test in Dieter has a central (main)                 
          memory and the TMP monitor is "operatively associated with"                  
          the central memory because it is attached to the system bus                  
          which functions to communicate with memory (Figure 3; note                   
          that the TMP can communicate with main memory, page 200,                     
          left col., last para.).  One of ordinary skill in the art                    
          would have understood that the processor under test in                       
          Dieter is connected to peripherals via the system bus                        
          because peripherals are conventional and necessary in                        
          computer systems to do anything useful, such as to display,                  
          enter, or print data.  The TMP monitor is also "operatively                  
          associated with" the peripherals via the system bus.                         
               For these reasons, we find the "first pickups means" is                 
          taught by Dieter.                                                            
               The Examiner reads (EA5) the "second means . . . for                    
          processing the instantaneous information" on the 68000 CPU                   
          of the TMP shown in Figure 3, page 200.  We agree.                           
          Appellant does not challenge this finding.  Thus, the                        
          "second means" is taught by Dieter.                                          

                                        - 12 -                                         





Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007