Ex parte CLAES - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1996-3076                                                         
          Application 08/118,773                                                       

          being executed," which we have interpreted to be the events.                 
          Thus, we find the status table limitation taught by Dieter.                  
               The Examiner states that the step of "authorizing                       
          access to the status table (TE), particularly in the reading                 
          mode, for service programs (SER) external to the observed                    
          program being executed" is "apparent from page 199 fig.2 and                 
          page 200 fig.3" (EA4).  More instructive is the discussion                   
          about the monitoring software (page 200, right col.) which                   
          has access to the stored events.  We find this limitation                    
          taught by Dieter.                                                            
               The Examiner finds the step of "retaining all or part                   
          of the status tables (TE) corresponding to observation                       
          cycles preceding the current cycle in memory in accordance                   
          with a structure of previous chronologically arranged status                 
          tables (TANT1-TANTN)" to be "an apparent process in                          
          collecting and storing information" (EA4).  Appellant argues                 
          that this step is not taught by Dieter (Br13-14).  The                       
          Examiner responds that Dieter teaches storing information                    
          with time stamps (EA12).                                                     
               We do not find anything in Dieter than can be                           
          interpreted to anticipate this "retaining" step.  A time                     

                                        - 7 -                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007