Ex parte NAGEL et al. - Page 2



            Appeal No. 1997-0159                                                                            
            Application 08/172,579                                                                          



                   b) directing said feed into the molten metal bath at a rate which causes the             
            concentration of carbon in the molten metal bath to be lower than the saturation limit for carbon
            of said bath at the operating conditions of said molten metal bath, whereby the hydrocarbon     
            component of the feed can exhibit cleavage of at least one carbon-carbon bond of the            
            hydrocarbon component of said feed; and                                                         
                   c) establishing and maintaining conditions in said molten metal bath to cause cleavage   
            of at least one carbon-carbon bond of the hydrocarbon component to produce unsaturated          
            organic compounds, as products of said cleavage.                                                
                   The sole reference now relied upon by the examiner is:                                   
            Nagel                           5,191,154                       Mar. 2, 1993                    
                   The appealed claims stand finally rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103 as unpatentable over    
            Nagel.  See the Examiner's Answer at page 3 and the final rejection entered on May 1, 1995      
            as Paper No. 10.                                                                                
                   We reverse.                                                                              
                   The subject matter on appeal relates to a method for reforming hydrocarbons into         
            shorter-chain unsaturated organic compounds, such as ethylene.  Reforming of hydrocarbons       
            is a defined process which involves the decomposition or cracking of hydrocarbon gases or       
            low-octane petroleum fractions by heat and pressure either with or without a catalyst.  See The 
            Condensed Chemical Dictionary, 10th Edition, edited by Hawley, copyright 1981 at pages 886      
            and 887, copy attached.  Appellants' claimed reforming method involves the steps of providing   
            a molten metal bath of an elemental metal which is capable of causing cleavage of at least one  
            carbon-carbon bond of hydrocarbon component of a hydrocarbon-containing feed.  The feed is      
            directed into the molten metal bath at a rate which causes the concentration of carbon in the   


                                                       2                                                    




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007