Ex parte ESMON et al. - Page 7




              Appeal No. 1997-0483                                                                                        
              Application No. 07/648,900                                                                                  


              polypeptide of amino acid residues 407 to 486 binds thrombin, thereby inhibiting its                        
              clotting activity, without increasing protein C activation (see p. 4, penultimate para.; p. 6,              
              para. 2; p. 7, para. 4; p. 9, para. 5; pp. 20--22, Examples 14-16; p. 25, para. 2).                         
                     Thus, we interpret the polypeptides of the claimed invention as encompassing                         
              polypeptides which identically correspond to residues 407 to 486 of a mammalian                             
              thrombomodulin as shown in Figure 6 as well as "similar" sequences having modifications                     
              both within the sequence, e.g., conservative substitutions at non-identical amino acid                      
              residues as suggested in specification Example 13, and additional substituents adjacent                     
              to the termini of the sequence, e.g., cross-linking groups suitable for attaching the                       
              polypeptide to a surface, and non-glycosylated derivatives thereof with the proviso that the                
              sequence must be capable of binding to thrombin, thereby inhibiting its clotting activity,                  
              without affecting, i.e., increasing, protein C activation.  We do not interpret claim 5 as                  
              reciting a polypeptide including additional amino acid residues up to and including                         
              residues 234 to 286, residues 310 to 486, or even the entire protein because such                           
              polypeptides significantly increase protein C activation (see e.g., specification, p. 4, para.              
                 5                                                                                                        
              5).                                                                                                         

                     5In the brief (pp. 18-19, § b.), appellants state:                                                   
                     The specification provides the amino acid sequences of thrombomodulin from several                   
                     species and describes which regions, and residues within regions, are conserved. It is               
                     readily apparent to one skilled in the art that if the protein contains substitutions for an         
                     amino acid residue but is still biologically active, that the substituted amino acid is not          
                     essential for activity.  Moreover, applicants have shown that not only are the claimed               
                     peptides active, but that longer fragments including other amino acids, up to and including          
                                                          - 7 -                                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007