Appeal No. 1997-0495 Application No. 08/399,787 The subject matter on appeal relates to a recordable element having a substrate and on the surface of the substrate, a recording layer comprising material having a certain formula and a light reflecting layer, wherein the light reflecting layer and the recording layer are selected such that the element reflectivity is about or greater than 70% at about 780 nm. Further details of this appealed subject matter are set forth in representative independent claim 1 which reads as follows: 1. A recordable element having a substrate and on the surface of the substrate, a recording layer and a light reflecting layer, the improvement comprising: a) a recording layer including material given by the formula (Te Ge C H O ), a, b, c, d, and e are atomic a b c de percents and (c + d) > 40, d > 10, a > 5, b > 5, and e >0 such that a + b + c + d + e = 100; and b) the light reflecting layer and the recording layer being selected such that the element R (element max reflectivity) is about or greater than 70% at about 780 nm. The references relied upon by the examiner as evidence of obviousness are: Chen et al. 5,242,784 Sep. 7, 1993 (Chen) (filed Jun. 22, 1992) Yamada et al. 5,273,861 Dec. 28, 1993 2Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007