Ex parte THUENTE - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1997-1215                                                        
          Application No. 08/092,684                                                  


          calculates a first velocity of the receiver from the GPS data               
          and receives a second velocity of the receiver from an                      
          inertial reference unit within the receiver.  Also, Yokouchi                
          discloses computing a difference between the first and second               
          velocities and compares this difference to a predetermined                  
          value.  The Examiner explains that Yokouchi does not                        
          explicitly disclose the use of carrier phase tracking but this              
          is found in the APA of the accumulated delta range technique,               
          and used to improve accuracy.  The Examiner also explains that              
          Yokouchi does not explicitly disclose indicating a cycle slip               
          error if the velocity difference exceeds a predetermined                    
          error, however, Lapucha suggests that a cycle slip has                      
          occurred based on the comparison of the data collected from                 
          the INS system and GPS system.  Thus one of ordinary skill in               
          the art would have been motivated to utilize the velocity                   
          difference data of Yokouchi as an indication of cycle slip                  
          error.  (Answer-pages 3 and 4.)                                             
                    There is no dispute that all aspects of the claimed               
          invention can be found in the three references applied in the               
          rejection (Brief-page 5).  However,  Appellant contends that                


                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007