Ex parte DAVIS - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1997-1264                                                        
          Application 07/882,560                                                      

          initialization and does not disclose an apparatus or method                 
          that resets a CPU regardless of whether the CPU is operating                
          in a fault-free state or a fault state [brief, pages 9-16].                 
          The examiner asserts that the non-maskable interrupt (NMI) of               
          Guziak operates as a notice of initialization.  The examiner                
          also argues that the CPU in Guziak is initialized in a fault-               
          free state because initialization can occur after a transient               
          fault is detected which is a fault-free state in Guziak                     
          [answer, pages 13-16].  Appellant responds that the examiner                
          has misconstrued the disclosure of Guziak [reply brief].                    
          We have carefully considered the disclosure of Guziak,                      
          and we generally agree with the position of appellant as                    
          expressed in the briefs.  Most importantly, we agree with                   
          appellant that the CPU of Guziak is not initialized or reset                
          when the CPU is in a fault-free operating state.  Guziak                    
          indicates that if a transient fault has been detected and is                
          corrected by the reinitialization, that fault will not be                   
          detected a second time and the CPU resumes suspended                        
          operations.  Thus, reinitialization has occurred as a result                
          of a transient fault which is a fault state of operation and                
          not a fault-free state as argued by the examiner.  In other                 

                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007