Ex parte HERT et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 1997-1299                                                         
          Application 08/393,746                                                       


          encapsulated by at least one ethylene polymer having units                   
          derived from unsaturated epoxy monomers or from unsaturated                  
          acid anhydride monomers.                                                     
               EP ‘280 discloses a rubber-like polymer dispersed in an                 
          amorphous polymer such that at least part of the rubber-like                 
          polymer is in the form of a stringy structure or a two-                      
          dimensional or three-dimensional network structure (page 5,                  
          lines 36-37; page 6, lines 1-2 and 9-10).  The rubber-like                   
          polymer can be any rubber-like polymer having a storage shear                
          modulus at room temperature of 5 x 10  dyne/cm  or less (page8       2                              
          5, lines 17-19).  The exemplified rubber-like polymers include               
          olefin rubber-like copolymers such as ethylene-propylene                     
          rubber, ethylene-butene rubber and ethylene-propylene-butene                 
          rubber (page 5, lines 20-24).                                                
               The Epstein references are relied upon by the examiner                  
          for a suggestion to use in the EP ‘280 process an ethylene                   
          polymer having units derived from unsaturated epoxy monomers                 
          or from unsaturated acid anhydride monomers (answer, page 3).                
               The examiner argues that figures 3 and 4 of EP ‘280 show                
          a rubber-like polymer in the form of a network structure in an               


                                           4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007