Ex parte TRUMMER et al. - Page 22




          Appeal No. 1997-1351                                                         
          Application 08/127,924                                                       

               The Examiner's reasoning is not understood.  The                        
          display 22 is not connected via the SMC channel or the SCP                   
          channel to the RISC-based processor bus 208.  "Channel 200                   
          and time-share portions of elements 201-208 together make up                 
          DMA serial controller 3 [of figure 1]."  (Col. 3,                            
          lines 46-48.)  Display 22 only communicates via time-shared                  
          SCC channel 200.                                                             
               Nevertheless, the term "connected to" in the phrase                     
          "the plurality of peripheral devices are connected to both                   
          the control bus and the remainder bus" is very broad and                     
          does not require a "separate" or "independent" connection                    
          between a peripheral device and each of the two buses, nor                   
          does it require a "direct" connection to the bus.  The term                  
          "connected to" does not preclude the presence of intervening                 
          elements; e.g., display 22 is "connected to" RISC-based                      
          processor bus 208 even though it is connected via the                        
          intervening elements of interface 18, multiplexing                           
          interface 201, and channel 200.  Therefore, the limitation                   
          of "the plurality of peripheral devices are connected to                     
          both the control bus and the remainder bus" is broad enough                  
          to include the arrangement in Petty where the display is                     

                                        - 22 -                                         





Page:  Previous  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007