Ex parte COLELLA et al. - Page 9




          Appeal No. 1997-1594                                                        
          Application No. 08/247,090                                                  

          layer and includes carbide forming materials such as tungsten               
          and braze- able material such as copper.  See column 4, line                
          66 through column 5, line 12.  The infiltrating alloy includes              
          copper alloys.  See column 5, lines 13-18.  Our position is                 
          supported by the specification which discloses tungsten as a                
          carbide forming element.  See page 7, and copper alloys as                  
          brazeable infiltrating materials.  See specification, page 8.               
          Accordingly, we conclude that Chen discloses the elements of                
          coating diamond particles with an adherent carbide forming                  
          material and brazeable material as required by the claimed                  
          subject matter.                                                             
          Although porosity is not specifically mentioned, we                         
          conclude that the intermediate product necessarily must be                  
          porous since the alloys disclosed by Chen, including copper-                
          based alloys infiltrate the assembly of diamond particles.                  
          A compacting step and heating step are performed both by                    
          vibrational packing, see column 5, lines 22-26 and by ”hot                  
          pressing” taught at column 5, lines 38-41.  We conclude that                
          both compacting steps result in diamond particles in the form               
          of a porous body.                                                           



                                          9                                           





Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007