Ex parte DOCKNER et al. - Page 7




          Appeal 1997-1635                                                            
          Application 08/319,667                                                      

                              (3) JP-A 117 716/75,                                    
          none of which are written in English.                                       
                         a.   We have been able to decipher but two of                
          the documents given that we have been favored with                          
          translations only of (1) and (2).                                           
                         b.   In the Examiner's Answer, a reference is                
          made to prior art identified as:                                            
                   "90 48438, Mitsubishi Rayon (Japan), 03-1984."                     
          The "03-1984" would appear to straightforwardly translate into              
          March 1984, both in English and Japanese.                                   
                         c.   We have a copy of PTO Translation No. 00-               
          2259 in the file wrapper, prepared under the direction of the               
          Scientific Library of the PTO, which in all respects appears                
          to be translation of "Document No. 03-3646."  But, what does                
          "03-3646" have to do with "90 48438" cited by the examiner?                 
                         d.   Buried underneath all the important papers              
          in the file wrapper, we located--not without some effort--a                 
          curious one-page abstract attached to Japanese Patent Document              
          59-48438.  A copy of the abstract accompanies this opinion as               
          Appendix 1.                                                                 



                                        - 7 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007