Appeal No. 1997-2340 Page 9 Application No. 08/329,687 Although Takahashi teaches detecting, it does not detect the self-turning-on of a switching element absent an ON command. To the contrary, "a partial turn-off phenomenon itself is detected ...." Col. 7, ll. 11-12. The reference describes the phenomenon as follows. In more detail, when many thyristors are turned off, reverse voltages are required to be applied across the corresponding thyristors during long enough intervals that all of the thyristors can withstand forward voltages subsequently applied thereto. In case these reverse voltage intervals are insufficient, when a forward voltage is applied across the thyristors, some thyristors can withstand the forward voltage, but the remaining thyristors fail to perform forward recovery, i.e., recover their features to withstand the forward voltage, with the result that they maintain their conductive states. This phenomenon is a so-called partial turn-off phenomenon. Col. 1, ll. 28-40. In summary, Takahashi detects partial turn-off of some thyristors rather than their self-turning-on. For its part, although Mitsuoka teaches detecting, it does not detect the self-turning-on of a switching element absent an ON command. To the contrary, "the main current path of the GTO 1 is provided with a current detector 13 forPage: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007