Ex parte JOHNSON et al. - Page 4


              Appeal No. 97-2914                                                                                           
              Application No. 08/448,060                                                                                   

                     A duct for providing flue gas containing SO3 and SO2 produced by burning fossil fuel (pp. 302         
                            and 303).3  The SO3 can be highly corrosive, especially when the SO3 reacts with water         
                            to form sulfuric acid (para. bridging pp. 302 and 303).                                        
                     A particulate collection means for removing particles from the flue gas to produce a partially        
                            cleaned flue gas (p. 309, Fig. 7-2, Ash Collector).                                            
                     A flue means for conveying the partially cleaned flue gas from the particulate collection means       
                            (Fig. 7-2).                                                                                    
                     Means for injecting an aqueous solution of Ca, Mg, or Na based reagents (p. 308, Table 7-7)           
                            wherein make-up limestone is fed to the wet scrubber means through the limestone               
                            slurry tank (p. 309, Fig. 7-2).                                                                








                     5.     A wet scrubber means for removing SO2 from the substantially SO3-free flue gas, which          
                            B                                                                                              
                            makes a wet reagent with materials such as lime (CaO), limestone (CaCO3), and                  
                                    magnesium oxide (MgO) (p. 308, Table 7-7; compare, present claim 11, and               
                                    p. 7, lines 20-24, of the present specification),                                      
                            reacting the wet reagent with the SO2 in the wet scrubber means to remove SO2 from             
                                    the flue gas (p. 306, Figure 7-1; and pp. 307-320).                                    
              There are differences between the teachings of Kohl and the claimed invention.                               
                                                                                                                           
              3 The Aflue@ in flue gas is a duct.                                                                          
                            4                                                                                              




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007