Ex parte KIM - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1997-3964                                                        
          Application No. 08/319,658                                                  


          D  corresponds to switching signal D  (column 4, lines 504                               3                                         
          through 56).  In a schematic illustration of the position                   
          detecting switches 49a and 49b (Figure 5), “[a]n electrically               
          conductive wiper W rotates with the motor M " (column 5, lines              
                                                     1                                
          22 and 23) (emphasis added).  According to Teranishi, “[w]hen               
          the motor M  reaches an angular position that places the first              
                     1                                                                
          mode changing means (FIG. 1A) in the PB mode, the wiper W                   
          establishes electrical contact between a contact A and a                    
          ground contact G" (column 5, lines 28 through 31).  “As FIG. 6              
          shows, . . . D  indicates the mode changing mechanism is in a               
                        s                                                             
          position corresponding to the PB mode of the tape recorder”                 
          (column 5, lines 33 through 36).  Thus, Teranishi is                        
          “detecting a motor rotation signal [of M ] indicative of the                
                                                  1                                   
          rotating direction of said motor” as claimed with the position              
          detectors 49a and 49b.  The switching signal D  and the motor               
                                                        4                             
          rotation signal D  are combined in comparator 48, and, if they              
                           s                                                          
          match, then the control circuit of Figure 2 knows the switched              
          mode of the mechanism (column 5, lines 45 through 51).                      
               In summary, all of the limitations of claim 1 are found                
          in Teranishi.  Although the rejection is based on the admitted              
          prior art, Fukuyama and Teranishi, it is permissible to                     
                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007