Ex parte UTSUMI et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1997-4018                                                        
          Application No. 08/668,716                                                  


          telephone line to connect the local and remote facsimile                    
          machines and also an exclusive line between the local                       
          facsimile machine and the computer.                                         
               As to the first argument, Lin states (column 12, lines                 
          14-25) that the communication between the local and remote fax              
          machines is rare because the computer is "directly                          
          communicable with the remote fax machines. . . .  However,                  
          with the two functions of (E)[fax machine to central office],               
          and (F)[central office to fax machine], if the computer has                 
          trouble, the fax machine can still work independently to                    
          communicate with the remote facsimile stations."  If the                    
          computer has difficulty communicating directly with the remote              
          fax machine, and the local fax machine is to make the                       
          communication, the computer must instruct the local fax                     
          machine as to the desired correspondence.  Accordingly, Lin                 
          actually does suggest the interposition of a facsimile machine              
          between the computer and a remote facsimile machine, albeit                 
          only under certain circumstances.                                           
               Regarding the second argument, however, we find no                     
          suggestion of an exclusive line between the local fax machine               
          and the computer.  In Lin's system, communication between the               
                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007