Ex parte OVERTURF et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 1997-4219                                                        
          Application No. 08/315,745                                                  

          the claims requires the generation of a “cross reference” or a              
          cross referencing system.  The cross referencing system, as                 
          disclosed, requires an input of a first set of data items from              
          the source application system [see 9 in Figure 1] and another               
          input of a second set of data items from the target                         
          application system [see 35 in Figure 1].  The cross                         
          referencing system, coupled to receive these two sets of                    
          data, generates a cross referencing repository in response to               
          these inputs.  Translation takes place based on the cross                   
          reference generated.                                                        
               Claims 2 and 7 are very specific about the cross                       
          referencing system requiring inputs from both the source                    
          application system and the target application system.  While                
          not as specific, claim 1 does call for the generation of a                  
          cross reference between a first set of data items from the                  
          source application system and a second set of data items from               
          the target application system.  So, even claim 1 requires some              
          input from the target application system to the cross                       
          referencing system.  Claim 9, while somewhat broader in many                
          aspects, still calls for a means for cross referencing data                 
          items in a source application system program with data items                

                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007