Ex parte BOUTAGHOU - Page 3




          Appeal No. 98-0592                                                           
          Application 08/463,168                                                       

               been subjected to a shock of a predetermined amount.                    

               The appellant has argued all claims 13-15 together as a                 
          single group.  See Brief at page 3.                                          
                                       Opinion                                         
               The rejection of claims 13-15 cannot be sustained.                      
               A reversal of the rejection on appeal should not be                     
          construed as an affirmative indication that the appellant’s                  
          claims are patentable over prior art.  We address only the                   
          positions and rationale as set forth by the examiner and on                  
          which the examiner’s rejection of the claims on appeal is                    
          based.                                                                       
               According to claim 13, the disk drive includes a base, at               
          least one disk attached to the base, an actuator also attached               
          to the base, which actuator includes a transducer positioned                 
          over the at least one disk, a cover attached to the base to                  
          form an enclosure for the at least one disk and the                          
          transducer, and a shock sensitive sensor.  Further according                 
          to claim 13, the cover or the base includes “a window for                    
          viewing inside the enclosure,”  and the shock sensitive sensor               
          is “attached to one of said cover and said base within said                  


                                          3                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007