Appeal No. 1998-0889 Application 08/006,585 applicant's challenge to a finding of Official Notice, the references should be made part of the official rejection. The rejection we review is the one in the statement of the rejection. Obviousness Hakamatsuka discloses a system for issuing ID cards in which image data (e.g., a person's photograph, signature, etc.) and attribute data (e.g. name, employee number, address, telephone number, etc., col. 6, lines 26-28) are printed onto a pre-manufactured blank card having fixed information such as a design, the company's mark, etc. (col. 8, lines 46-48; col. 12, lines 37-57, referring to figure 15). Gradational images such as a photograph and handwritten signature are printed out by a sublimation transfer method and non-gradational images such as a name are printed out by a thermal transfer method to make best use of the properties of the two methods (col. 6, lines 48-55; figure 10). Hakamatsuka discloses that a flat transfer apparatus can be used where the cards are not flexible enough for a roll transfer apparatus (col. 11, lines 36-41). It is further disclosed (col. 13, lines 17-24): The processing can be effected directly on a substrate, and no post-processing is needed. Since recording can be effected through editing process, it is possible to completely match each individual identification photograph, code information, - 6 -Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007