Ex parte GRAAB et al. - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1998-1002                                                        
          Application No. 08/390,175                                                  


               Indeed, the only reference relied upon by the examiner                 
          directed to cross-linkable elastomeric patterned floor                      
          coverings is Heckel.                                                        
          Heckel is directed to patterned floor coverings from a                      
          preform of rubber wherein the rubber is mixed with                          
          contrastingly colored zones.  See Abstract.  The zones in the               
          floor covering are formed by mixing a rubber mixture of one                 
          color with contrastingly colored particles of another color.                
          See column 1, lines 55-61.  We find that Heckel states that                 
          “[t]he rubber mixture and the particles used in the mixing                  
          step of the invention are dyed differently to have contrasting              
          colors.  The rubber material forming the particles is in, at                
          least, an advanced state of vulcanization compared to the                   
          rubber mixture.  The particles thereby are inhibited during                 
          vulcanization of the blank from softening with the rubber                   
          mixture, which precludes mutual mixing of the dyes contained                
          in the particles and in the rubber.”  See column 2, lines 32-               
          40.  Based upon the above statement, it is evident that the                 
          particle sections differ in color from that of the base                     
          sheeting.  Furthermore, when different color particles are                  
          utilized, the color of each necessarily remains different from              
                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007