Ex parte ARCHIBALD et al. - Page 15




          Appeal No. 1998-1289                                                        
          Application 07/906,492                                                      


                 in FIGURE 4f [column 4, line 58, through column                      
                 5, line 5].                                                          

            The rim part 67 and loose flange 68 formed by this                        
            process are adapted to be attached to the integral disc                   
            and rim part shown in Figure 1d (see column 4, lines 55                   
            through 58).                                                              


                 Adams fails to meet a number of limitations in                       
            independent claim 31 including those requiring the                        
            provision of a wheel disc which includes an outboard tire                 
            retaining flange, the formation of a unitary dual rim                     
            preform having an inboard tire retaining flange and tire                  
            bead seat at each axial end, the splitting of the unitary                 
            dual rim preform to produce two separate partial wheel                    
            rims having an inboard tire retaining flange and tire                     
            bead seat at one end, and the positioning the wheel disc                  
            and one of the partial wheel rims in a fixture for                        
            attachment.  The examiner’s apparent determination (see                   
            page 4 in the final rejection and page 6 in the main                      
            answer) that Adams’ loose flange 68 constitutes or could                  
            be used as a partial wheel rim of the sort recited in                     
                                         15                                           





Page:  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007