Ex parte BULFER - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1998-2705                                                        
          Application No. 08/867-773                                                  


               On pages 6 and 7 of the brief, Appellant argues that                   
          neither Hou nor McMahan teaches or suggests all the features                
          of Appellant's claimed limitations.  In particular, Appellant               
          argues that Hou and McMahan fail to teach or suggest the steps              
          recited in Appellant's claim 1 as follows:                                  
               prompting the caller to initiate a first call to the                   
               automated system; initiating a second call in the                      
               network to a facility for performing speech                            
               recognition; [and] bridging the first and second                       
               calls.                                                                 
          In particular, Appellant argues that Hou does not teach                     
          Appellant's step of initiating a second call in a network to a              
          speech recognition system.  Rather, the Hou patent teaches                  
          placing a first call to a voice directed communications                     
          system.  The voice directed communications system then                      
          launches a second call to a destination specified by the first              
          call.  Appellant argues that Hou contemplates an entirely                   
          different process than Appellant's step of initiating a second              
          call to a speech recognition system.  Appellant further argues              
          that McMahan does not teach placing calls to a speech                       
          recognition system because McMahan performs the speech to DTMF              
          conversion in the telephone itself.                                         
               On page 6 of the Answer, the Examiner responds to the                  
                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007