Ex parte RONNBERG et al. - Page 11




          Appeal No. 1998-3367                                                        
          Application No. 08/545,717                                                  


          stiffness between 25 g and 90 g, it is possible to achieve                  
          good handling characteristics (specification, page 5).                      
               Turning to Gipson, we appreciate that Gipson does not                  
          expressly state what the stiffness of the waist belt is as                  
          measured by the modified ASTM test used by appellants.                      
          Nevertheless, it is self-evident that Gipson’s waist belt has               
          some stiffness value as measured by that standard.  The                     
          characteristics of the waist belt of concern to Gipson are                  
          discussed in columns 3 and 4.  We are informed at column 3,                 
          lines 10-17, that the belt should not be too wide nor too                   
          narrow, least it fail to provide for adequate adjustment to                 
          fit the wearer or interfere with leg movement of the wearer.                
          Column 3, lines                                                             
          24-25, states that the waist belt should be nonirritating to                
          the skin.  From column 3, lines 49-50, we learn that the belt               
          can be of single or double thickness.  At column 4, lines 28-               
          41, it is stated that the sides of the waist belt may be                    
          reinforced, but that in so doing, the reinforcement should be               
          smooth, nonirritating to the skin, and not provide an undue                 
          increase in thickness, because otherwise the wearer could                   
          experience discomfort.                                                      
                                         11                                           





Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007