Ex parte MATSUMOTO et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1999-0899                                                        
          Application No. 08/654,752                                                  



          is to be molded is held in place in mold 1 by a barrier plate               
          7 of "strip metal-like magnets" (page 7, lines 8 to 11), the                
          decorating material 11 having iron powder (page 6, lines 17                 
          to 20) at its edge to enable the magnetic barrier plate 7 to                
          hold                                                                        
          it in place.  It appears that the barrier plate 7 encircles                 
          the area of the mold in which the decorating material 11 is                 
          located, and when the mold is closed, the barrier plate forms               
          a dent 23 at the edge of the decorating material 11, as well                
          as in material 22 (Fig. 2 and page 7, lines 16 to 24).                      
               Given the disclosure of Idetsuki as outlined above, we do              
          not consider that one of ordinary skill would find therein any              
          teaching or suggestion to form a perforation in the bracket 46              
          of Strapazzini in the manner recited in claim 13.  While                    
          Idetsuki does disclose a protrusion 7 on one of the molds 1,                
          the protrusion does not form a perforation in the material                  
          being molded, but only dents it.  Thus, one of ordinary skill               
          would not, in our view, derive from Idetsuki any teaching of                
          forming                                                                     
          a perforation in the material being molded.                                 

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007