Ex parte WALSH - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1999-2624                                         Page 7         
          Application No. 08/561,658                                                  


          the claimed invention.  As discussed above, Crawford discloses              
          a joint between the tube and the probe including a force fit                
          engagement of the proximal end of the probe by a first end of               
          the tube and, if preferred, a medical grade adhesive for                    
          bonding the tube to the probe.  There is no suggestion in                   
          Crawford or in Fugoso that the Crawford joint might be                      
          inadequate for its intended purpose.  It is only the                        
          appellant's disclosure (specification, pages 3-4) which                     
          informs us of any perceived deficiencies in the Crawford                    
          device.  Fugoso discloses a joint not between a light metal                 
          wire probe and a flexible tube but, rather, between two nylon               
          or polyethylene lumen shafts of a dilation catheter through                 
          which inflation fluid is passed to inflate and deflate a                    
          dilation balloon on the distal end of the catheter.  According              
          to Fugoso, the lap joint heat shrunk sleeve allows the two                  
          lumen shafts to be in fluid communication with each other.  As              
          the Crawford joint is between a metal wire probe and a tube                 
          rather than between two flexible tubes placed end to end and                
          as there is no need for fluid to pass through the joint region              
          between the tube and the probe of Crawford when used as                     









Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007