PARINS et al. V. SLATER - Page 7




          Interference No. 104,190                                                    



          fact that the parties ascribe different meanings to a count or              
          that the count is readable on more than one embodiment does                 
          not render the count ambiguous.  See id. at 32, 194 USPQ at                 
          547.                                                                        
                    Turning to the specific count at issue, the senior                
          party directs our attention to subparagraph (a) of the count                
          which reads as follows:                                                     
                    (a)  first and second metal blades each having a                  
          cutting edge and shearing surface, said first metal blade                   
          supporting an insulative layer on a surface other than the                  
          cutting edge and shearing surface thereof and an electrically               
          conductive electrode member on the insulative layer.                        
          The senior party argues that the count expression “said first               
          metal blade supporting an insulative layer . . . and an                     
          electrically conductive electrode member on the insulative                  
          layer,” requires that the first metal blade be the layer that               
          the other layers are affixed on, with the first metal blade                 
          extending back to the means for pivotally joining and carrying              
          the other layers.  The junior party argues that the above-                  
          referred to language merely requires that the first metal                   
          blade supports the other  two layers by providing                           
          reinforcement or strengthening of the other two layers, as an               


                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007