Ex parte SAAR - Page 6




          Appeal No. 2000-0327                                          Page 6            
          Application No. 08/745,330                                                      


          time, is addressed in col 2, lines 53-60 and col 6, line 68 to                  
          col 7, line 3."                                                                 
               Upon review of Thompson, we are in agreement with                          
          appellant (brief, page 5) that the flow sensors in Thompson                     
          only sense that there is water flow in the pipe, and that                       
          Thompson does not measure the volume of the flowing water.                      
          Thompson discloses (col. 12, lines 30-35) that "[f]rom the                      
          foregoing, it will be appreciated that a fluid management                       
          system is provided which acts as a water conservation tool,                     
          and which shuts down the fluid supply system to prevents [sic]                  
          leakage and loss when a fixture or water utilization device                     
          has been left running for too long."  The portions of Thompson                  
          referred to by the examiner indicate that the flow timing                       
          means are responsive to each flow sensor's output signal for                    
          timing the period during which the flow sensor measures flow,                   
          and do not measure the volume of the flowing water.  We find                    
          that the examiner has misinterpreted the language in Thompson                   
          (col. 6, lines 68 through col. 7, line 5) that "the flow                        
          sensors used on any system in accordance with the present                       
          invention should be capable of detecting extremely low (and                     
          forward) flow rates, preferably on the order of 0.1 gallons                     







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007