Appeal No. 2000-1472 Application No. 08/855,104 type valves including a shim (non-planar valve plate 124a). As to the language in claim 1 describing the shim as an annular member having an outer diameter that is not greater than the outer peripheral edges of the series of apertures with which it is associated, the examiner notes that “shim” 124a does not extend beyond the left most portion of aperture 122. With reference to Figure 3, the examiner describes Axthammer as disclosing a piston 218 dividing a cylinder 210 into first and second fluid chambers 12a and 12b, a first and second series of apertures 220 and 222 extending through the piston from one fluid chamber to the other, a first plate type valve (shown by plates 224b1, 224b2, 224a, 224c1, 224c2 and 224c3) for controlling the flow through the first and second series of apertures and a second plate type valve (shown in Fig. 3 located above apertures 220 and 222) for controlling the flow through the first and second series of apertures, at least one of the plate type valves comprising a shim 224a interposed between the plates for controlling the preload at which the one plate type valve opens to permit flow through 8Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007