Appeal No. 2000-1743 Application No. 09/314,618 Claim 3 adds the limitation that the hydraulic circuitry includes means for urging the 1-2 shift valve into an upshifted position, and that the method includes applying said fluid pressure to said predetermined end of said 1 - 2 shift valve sufficient to overcome said means for urging said 1 - 2 shift valve into said upshifted position to maintain said 1 - 2 shift valve in said downshifted position when said gear selector is in said first gear position. In the examiner's view (final rejection, page 5), Bouda discloses an automotive transmission that includes a manual valve (61) coupled to a gear selector and operatively associated with a 1-2 shift valve (63), "wherein a fluid flow path/passageway (102, 102a) is provided from the manual valve to a predetermined end (i.e., right-hand end in the drawings) of the 1-2 shift valve for applying a fluid pressure thereto sufficient to maintain . . . the 1-2 shift valve in a downshifted position (i.e., "1st FIX") without regard to vehicle speed when the gear selector is in a first gear position (1-range)." As for the means for urging the 1-2 shift valve into an upshifted position as set forth in claim 3, the examiner indicates that when the gear selector of Bouda is in the first gear position "the fluid pressure overcomes a 6Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007