Ex parte SMITH et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 2000-2006                                                        
          Application No. 09/027,173                                                  


          discloses a tarpaulin including a sheet (2), a plurality of                 
          elastic straps or cords (e.g., 4) and a reinforcing webbing                 
          (3) which extends around the perimeter of the sheet.  In                    
          addition, Hansen discloses (col. 7, line 62 - col. 8, line 12)              
          the use of safety reflective means secured to the tarp, for                 
          example, on one or more of the coverings (11), to increase the              
          visibility of the tarpaulin at night or in low visibility                   
          conditions such as inclement weather. In the examiner's view,               
          the tarpaulin of Hansen does not incorporate a retroreflective              
          sheeting onto the reinforcing                                               


          webbing or provide a teaching that the sheet can be attached                
          to the vehicle with non-elastic straps and buckles.                         


          To account for these differences between the tarpaulin of                   
          Hansen and the claimed subject matter, the examiner turns to                
          the teachings of Tolliver and Jones.  The examiner sees in                  
          Tolliver a teaching of a tarpaulin or truck trailer cover                   
          which has a retroreflective sheeting (46) incorporated onto a               
          perimeter of a sheet (40), and in Jones a teaching of a                     
          tarpaulin sheeting employing non-elastic straps (20, 30, 40)                
                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007