Ex Parte FREITAG et al - Page 5



          Appeal No. 2001-2176                                                        
          Application 09/031,186                                                      

          recitation of the sealing lip.  As described and shown in the               
          underlying specification and drawings, however, the sealing lip 2           
          does not at least partially enclose the supporting body 3.                  
          Hence, the language at issue appears, when read in light of the             
          specification, to be inaccurate, and raises questions as to                 
          whether it should refer instead to the earlier recitation in                
          claim 1 of the sealing body (as disclosed, the sealing body 1 is            
          made of an elastomeric material and at least partially encloses             
          the supporting body).                                                       
               Claim 1 also recites that the sealing body has “a sloped               
          surface facing the sealing lip.”  It is not clear what this                 
          sloped surface facing the sealing lip is, there being no apparent           
          description of same in the specification.  While the sealing body           
          does have a sloped surface which contacts the sloped portion of             
          the supporting body, this surface faces away from the sealing               
          lip, not toward it.                                                         
               Claim 1 further recites that “the sloped portion [of the               
          supporting body] is in contact with the sealing body and the                
          portion which contacts the sealing body faces toward the                    
          longitudinal axis of the toroidal supporting body.”  To begin               
          with, it is unclear whether “the portion which contacts the                 
          sealing body” refers back to the sloped portion or to some other            

                                          5                                           



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007