KALFAS et al. V. WEAVER et al. V. WEAVER et al. V. ROWLAND et al. - Page 7





                                  Conception                                        
             14. Inventors Rowland and Vergano testified that on or                 
        about 13 May 1991, they arrived at the idea of a three-lumen                
        catheter, where one of the lumens was for a guide wire, one for             
        injecting contrast fluid and one for containing a cutting wire              
         (RR 290, T 3).                                                             
             15. Bryan Eddy allegedly made a sketch showing the cross               
        section and dimensions of the three-lumen catheter conceived by             
        Vergano and Rowland, whereby an engineering drawing was completed           
        on 14 June 1991 (RR 011, 1 7).                                              
             16. The engineering drawing does not show or describe the              
        elements of the count (Rowland Ex. 2013).                                   
                          Actual reduction to Practice                              

             17. By October 11, 1991, inventors Eddy and Vergano and lab            
        technician Heidi Bell (Bell), created prototypes of the three               
        lumen catheter (RR 007, 1 12; 012, 1 9; and 016, 91 7).                     
             18. Eddy, Vergano and Bell all testified that the three                
        lumen catheter prototypes were as depicted in Figs. 1, 2, 4 and 9           
        of U.S. Patent 5,547,4694 , and includes a three-lumen catheter             
        body 11 having a lumen 17 for contrast fluid, a lumen 20 for a              
        cutting wire and a lumen 16 for a guide wire (Fig. 2), with                 



             4 U.S. patent 5,547,469 (application 08/242,168) is the                
        parent case of Rowland's involved application, for which Rowland            
        has been accorded benefit (Finding 3).                                      
                                        7                                           








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007