Ex parte LAZARUS et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 1997-1003                                                        
          Application No. 08/188,145                                                  


          active] element is bonded to said flex circuits by a                        
          planarizing layer of curable material having a pattern                      
          complementary to the electrode pattern."  In other words, the               
          curable material must be patterned complementary to the                     
          electrode pattern and must have a surface level with the                    
          electrodes.                                                                 
               The examiner states (Answer, page 4) that "planarizing                 
          layer" and phrases from other claims are "basically functional              
          recitations which do not alter the claimed combination of                   
          structural elements."  Thus, the examiner ignores the claim                 
          language noted above.                                                       
               Appellants argue (Brief, page 9) that "[t]he art does not              
          show a layer which planarizes - i.e., entirely fills and                    
          flattens an area between electrodes - yet provides direct                   
          electrical contact between the sheet and those electrodes over              
          a distributed area."  We agree.  As indicated by appellants                 
          (Brief, page 9), Larson discloses a thin epoxy bond 28 (or                  
          conductive adhesive) between the electrodes and the block of                
          piezoelectric material, Fujii shows conductive adhesive bonds               
          34 and 36 over the entire conductive layer and discloses that               
          the bond should be thin to assure good conductivity (between                
                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007